“In matters of conscience, the law of the majority has no place.” ― Mahatma Gandhi.

Religion has no place in Governance in a Democracy, unless it is a Democracy where "All People are Equal but Some People are More Equal than Others".

When the law was made in 1950 then it was clearly mentioned in the Indian Constitution how citizenship will be given to anyone who was born here. Anyone who has lived here for 11 years will get citizenship whether Hindu, Sikh, Christian or Muslim."


What is Sad is in a War no side will agree it is at fault. All this violence and bloodshed in the name of God and Religion and we are all victims as we are born into one religion or the other for no fault of ours. Religious Conflict is the main reason why the world is in such mess in 2020 ? Chaaha Hai Kya ? Paaya Hai Kya? Just pain and misery. Sad world we live in. Can Gods not take the responsibility and resolve this feud between themselves. Australian Fires brought the people together CAA fires have divided the Nation on religious grounds. Sad but True.

Thursday, 13 February 2020

072 - Amit Shah to Visit Bengal in March to Clear Confusion Over Citizenship Issues - News 18.com



The Bengal Assembly polls in 2021 will be a prestige battle for the BJP and political experts feel Shah’s scheduled visit in March, 45 days after Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s visit to Kolkata, says it all.

Sujit Nath | News18.com

Updated:February 13, 2020, 1:56 PM IST


Kolkata: Finding itself on the back foot over the National Register of Citizens (NRC) and the National Population Register (NPR), the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) has decided to send Amit Shah to Kolkata to clear the narrative among the masses on what the Centre’s is actually up to over NPR. He is set to visit the Eastern state in the first week of March.

After yesterday’s devastating poll results in the national capital and BJP’s desperation to win the 2021 Assembly polls in Bengal (as a face saving exercise), the party felt it necessary to address the issue clearly, especially in Bengal, amid "confusions among the public that NPR is linked with the NRC."

Shah will be in Kolkata for one day and besides having a public meeting, he will also have an internal party meeting to evaluate the present position of the party in Bengal in the booth level.

The NPR is a Register of usual residents of the country. It is being prepared at the local (village/sub-Town), sub-district, district, state and national level under provisions of the Citizenship Act 1955 and the Citizenship (Registration of Citizens and issue of National Identity Cards) Rules, 2003.

The objective of the NPR is to create an identity database of every usual resident in the country. The database would contain demographic as well as biometric particulars.

Among other states, Bengal Assembly poll will be a prestige battle for the BJP and political experts feel Shah’s scheduled visit in March (nearly 45 days after Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s visit Kolkata where he delivered speech on various issues including citizenship issue) says it all.

Mamata is vehemently opposing NPR, NRC and CAA and making repeated attempts through public rallies/speech to make people believe that NPR is linked with NRC.

She has also appealed all the states leaders (especially the Chief Ministers of North Eastern regions) to reject NPR, NRC and CAA by terming it "a dangerous game of the BJP."

“NPR is totally related to the NRC and the CAA. Pass a resolution everywhere to withdraw it,” she had said.

Sensing that the Opposition leaders (especially Mamata) who have successfully managed to play the anti-citizenship cards against the Centre, Shah on December 24, 2019 in an interview to a news agency had clarified that, “There is no link between the NRC and NPR; I am clearly stating this today. There is no need to debate on this (NRC) as there has been no discussion on it, PM Modi was right, therd has been no discussion on it yet either in the Cabinet or in the Parliament.”

There are nearly 31 per cent Muslim voters in Bengal and the anxiety among them cannot be ruled out as Shah is not budging on the citizenship issue. Though, Mamata Banerjee had vouched to fight tooth and nail but the fear is evident among the Muslim community in the bordering areas in Bengal.

As per the Chief Minister, in Bengal so far 30 people have died due to NRC fears including three alone in Bashirhat. Most of them died after a failed struggle to put papers in line, including those showing pre-1971 lineage – as per the NRC cut-off year in Assam.

Earlier, on December 16, 2019 (five days after Citizenship Amendment Bill (CAB) was passed in the Rajya Sabha on December 11, 2019) Bengal government was the first to take an official step against CAA and NRC by staying process of NPR across the state.

In an official circular numbered ‘392-Home (NPR)/O/Cen-02/19’ dated December 16, 2019 – the letter, issued by the additional secretary, Home and Hill Affairs Department, reads, “I am directed to inform you that all activities regarding the preparation and updation of the National Population Register (NPR) are hereby stayed in West Bengal. No activity regarding NPR may be taken up without prior clearance from the state government.”

Not the least, on January 27, West Bengal became the fourth opposition-ruled state to pass a resolution against the CAA in its assembly, after Kerala, Punjab and Rajasthan.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

BJP mulls strategy change to counter West Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee
Following the party's loss in Delhi polls, Union Home Minister Amit Shah is likely to visit Bengal in March to review the BJP's CAA pitch.


Published: 14th February 2020 09:50 AM | Last Updated: 14th February 2020 09:50 AM | A+A A-



Union Home Minister Amit Shah. (Photo| PTI)
By Pranab Mondal
Express News Service

KOLKATA: With a view to counter West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee’s aggressive protests against the amended Citizenship Act and National Population Register (NPR), Union Home Minister Amit Shah is likely to visit Bengal in March.

According to the BJP sources, the decision of sending a heavyweight national leader to Bengal was taken after the party’s debacle in Delhi elections. "Initially it was decided that national president JP Nadda will visit Bengal but the high-command decided to send Shah. It is because the chief minister has been opposing CAA tooth and nail and we need a leader like Shah or Modi to combat it," said a senior BJP leader.

Since last year, the demand for NRC to weed out infiltrators and the new citizenship law has emerged as the latest flashpoint in the state with the Trinamool Congress opposing them tooth and nail and the BJP pressing for their implementation. Since the CAB was passed in the Rajya Sabha in December last year, the Bengal chief minister has been hitting roads to lead protest marches and addressing rallies urging people to oppose it and not produce any document before any government officials.

After BJP’s defeat in Delhi Assembly elections, poll managers of its Bengal unit are divided whether to push its aggressive strategies on the CAA-NRC or mellow it down and replace it with alternative plans of governance. While a section of leaders believes to keep up the tempo and aggressive strategy on CAA-NRC issue, another section prefers to highlight the governance issue along with the two factors.

"In Bengal, we took our tally from 2 to 18 out of 42 Lok Sabha seats and swept all the seven Lok Sabha seats in Delhi in 2019 general elections. But within a few months, the results are completely opposite in assembly polls in Delhi. We cannot take for granted that just because we won 18 seats in Bengal, we will also win the Bengal assembly elections in 2021. We need to change our strategy for state assembly elections. It should also lay similar stress and alternative and better governance," said a BJP leader in Bengal.

Echoing the same, the saffron camp’s ideologue and Rajya Sabha MP, Swapan Dasgupta, "Not only CAA, we need to highlight better governance issues with equal priority."